If you find a bunny under the Coney Island boardwalk, he ran off during the bulldozing of the Boardwalk community garden on Saturday morning. This isn’t a “coney” joke, but something we learned from the site manager. And when a gardener collected her chickens she also walked off with three kittens. The mama cat kept coming back all day looking for them. Such was the chaos that ensued in the animal kingdom when the 16-year-old boardwalk garden was abruptly razed and the plants were plowed under on Saturday to make way for the seating area for an amphitheater slated to open in June 2015.
We support the rehab of the landmark Childs Building, which tourists frequently refer to as “those ruins on the Boardwalk.” But it’s barbaric to bulldoze a garden, especially at 5am on a holiday weekend, no matter the circumstances. Waking up to photos and videos of the destruction posted on Facebook brought back memories of the infamous pre-dawn demolition of the Thunderbolt roller coaster by Mayor Giuliani in 2000. It also calls to mind Thor Equities CEO Joe Sitt’s demo of the Henderson Music Hall and Bank of Coney Island in 2010, which cruelly put a halt to Save Coney Island’s efforts to create a historic district.
The community gardeners along with the New York City Community Garden Coalition are expected to call a press conference to address the demolition in the next couple of days. “The Community and the NYCCGC will not let this action stand without a fight,” said the Coalition in a post on their Facebook page. [UPDATE: The press conference will be on Monday, December 30, 11 am, at 3099 W 22nd Street, between Surf Avenue and the Boardwalk, said NYCCGC in a release issued this afternoon.]
As previously noted (“Clock Ticking on Plan for the Landmark Childs Building,” ATZ, September 25, 2013), the City has the funds to bring the landmark back to life since Borough President Marty Markowitz will be able to use $50 million set aside in 2010 for a $64 million amphitheater in Asser Levy Park that was halted by a lawsuit. If the $50 million isn’t spent by the time the Borough President’s third term ends on December 31, 2013, it would go back into the public coffers and be lost to Coney Island. The landmark building’s deteriorating condition is also cause for concern. After Sandy, parts of the terracotta facade cracked and began falling off.
Just before Christmas, developer iStar Financial won approval from the City Council for the amphitheater project. The officially “decommissioned” garden was set to be relocated to a site five blocks away. Why was it necessary to raze it, without giving the gardeners an opportunity to collect their belongings and animals and make the move? Among the items that were reportedly destroyed was a “Coney totem,” a sculpture by artist Philomena Marano.
Marty Cottingham, a consultant to iStar, cited safety concerns and the need to do environmental testing and, if necessary, remediation as required by the DEP for property that was flooded during Sandy. “We have taken great lengths to do the right thing,” he told ATZ, noting that some items were put in the Childs Building and are available for pick-up. Improvements have been made at the alternate garden site, known as Surfside Garden, on Surf Avenue at 29th Street, including new topsoil and raised beds. Some gardeners say the new site is not suitable due its smaller footprint and being hemmed in by buildings. Others who were promised help relocating felt betrayed by the lack of warning.
The amphitheater project will be developed and operated by a partnership between an affiliate of iStar’s Coney Island Holdings LLC and non-profit Coney Island USA with $53 million in City capital funds, and involves the restoration and adaptive reuse of the Childs building as well as the development of a 5,100 seat amphitheater with a neighborhood park and playground on city-owned land overlooking the beachfront. In addition to approximately 40 to 50 free and paid concerts during the outdoor concert season, the developer promises to host community-based events throughout the year.
The Childs Building along with adjacent lots rezoned for high rise condos became part of iStar’s portfolio when Taconic Investment Partners defaulted on loans. The rezoning plan approved by the City Council in 2009 put 26 high rise residential towers and 5,000 new units of housing in Coney Island, including beachfront condos on 5.5 blocks of vacant land just west of MCU Park.
Related posts on ATZ…
December 2, 2013: New Construction: Coney Island Area’s 1st Hotel in Decades
November 28, 2013: Photo Album: Parachute Jump Lights Way to Year-Round Coney Island
October 30, 2013: Photo Album: Four Transformations, One Year After Sandy
October 7, 2012: ATZ’s Big Wish List for the New Coney Island
they placed new taller fencing around the property with safety netting behind the steel fence. Why the safety netting?? So people cant climb down it??
isn’t that standard for a construction site with chain link fencing already in place (versus wooden construction fencing)?
They aren’t going to do construction for a year?? I think they just don’t want people to climb and occupy the lot
Developer’s press release says work to begin immediately “includes clearing to facilitate environmental investigation and, if necessary, remediation as required by NYCDEP for property that was flooded during Sandy.”
The cats that live along the boardwalk because they have been abandoned and viewed as a nuisance are Casualties of this Development. No one seems to care about the kittens that were probably bulldozed over along with this garden. THEY ARE NOT GARBAGE. Please read this link for the ongoing misery that these cats are enduring and what we are trying to do in the name of Humanity. Let’s be civilized and try to relocate them, adopt them and do the right thing by these animals we like to refer to as Pets.
http://newyork.craigslist.org/brk/pet/4265353401.html
I often take walks along the Boardwalk, I even think I walked by you today, saw someone with what looked like cat food in a plastic bag walking off the Boardwalk by Childs. I do see the cats either laying in the grass by Stillwell or drinking rain water on West 16. I do feel sad seeing this and wish you luck.
[…] been up to, John Cusack? [SLAMXHYPE] Coney Island community garden bulldozed for amphitheater [Amusing the Zillion] Which neighborhoods had the biggest increase in murders this year? [Runnin' […]
Reality is the site was toxic after Sandy. Anyone who would eat or feed their family food from this sand/soil is a fool. Also if you took the time to see the site with your own eyes you would have seen it was more a trash dump than a garden. After talking with multiple Local residence – this site was used iligally by 40 members of the same family and they used it like a private club and on many occasions locals that tried to enjoy it as well were rudly scared away. Good by community DUMP!!!
Everyone can see for themselves the photo taken Sept, 2013 that appears on this website that the site was NOT a trash dump. I also have seen this with my own eyes. It is NOT a trash dump. Why are you labeling it as such??